Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Whalefall (2026)

 


This movie is a male weepy disguised as an adventure film,  which is perfectly acceptable to me. Sometimes it makes sense to hide an emotional gut punch inside a story that's filled with tension and fear and a big freaking whale.  Kevin Costner doesn't ask his dead father to play catch, but Josh Brolin might just as easily have said the same thing with different words in this movie.

Before I talk about the emotional components of the film, let's talk about the technical aspects and the adventure story that they encompass. It seems almost impossible to believe that we are going to watch a movie about a man who is consumed by a whale. I'm not sure that Jonah could make it more believable. Amazingly though, the scenario plays out in a pretty convincing way. Through a combination of bad timing and dumb decision making, our hero, played by Austin Abrams, in his wetsuit, air tank and regulator gets pulled inside a whale,  and like James Franco in “ 127 Hours" has to figure out what it all means and how to get out.

The production design on this is pretty effective. I don't know exactly what the digestive tract of a giant whale is going to look like, but I was convinced I was getting the authentic here. The only thing that made me question what I was seeing was the presence of light inside of a whale. The storyteller gives us a reason why there might be some illumination, and even turns it into a bit of character humor, in spite of the fact that it can't explain nearly as much of the illumination as exists in these scenes. The practical effects which are used to show some of the interior help make the danger feel more realistic. 

I saw this actor a week ago in another film where he's the main character and has to carry the story solo for most of the film. Both " Whalefall" and "Resident Evil" present our characters in isolation for most of the film, and Austin Abrams ,who I had first not recognized from last year's "Weapons", carries both films on his shoulders with ease.  I think this young man has a great career in front of him.

Like any desperate situation presented in films the audience is going to wonder what they would do in the same circumstances. It helps that our character has some background in scuba diving,  and that his father was also a harsh mentor who instilled in him knowledge that ultimately was going to be of critical importance. Josh Brolin appears mostly in flashback scenes as the father  who is never satisfied. Resentment by the son leads to a divide between the two of them, and just like in "Field of Dreams" we need a supernatural postmortem to resolve those issues.



In a few places there are pretentious passages of dialogue about nature, climate change, and what it means to be a man. Most of these character points sit in the background largely irrelevant, until one or two ideas crop up and become the gist of the last Act of the film. Man against nature has always been a theme in the movies, and it usually works, just as it does in this film. The Script attempts to create more emotional depth and I'm sure that's probably a reflection of the original book. There is a large psychological pill that you have to swallow in the end to make this movie work. If you can’t believe one can come back from the dead to play baseball, you aren't going to buy what happens here. If on the other hand having catch with your dead dad, chokes you up a little bit, then this movie is probably going to work for you. As a bonus it looks pretty great.

No comments: