I am a David Lynch fan, but I am not a completist. The man directed over a hundred projects, including television episodes, shorts and music videos. His list of feature length films is relatively small, only 10 really. Of those ten I have seen eight, with "Mulholland Drive" being my most recent, and the one I have waited the longest to see. This is a film that came out 24 years ago, and up to last Saturday, I had not spent the time to watch it. If I had to venture a reason why, it might be that the plot sounded a lot like "Lost Highway" with characters becoming completely different people in the course of the story. Lost Highway is the one movie my wife attended with me that she walked out on. I stayed and watched it to the end, but I know I was very confused and I have not returned to it. I think I also suffered from the misnomer that this was a Black and White film, and it would be murky. That set off hesitation and I never took the plunge. With the recent passing of Lynch, the Alamo Drafthouse Cinema Chain has been playing a number of retrospective films and I decided it was unfathomable for me to hold out any longer.
In the end, I think I made the right choice not trying to catch up with this on video, and seeing it for the first time in a theater. This movie is a masterpiece and probably sits in my top three Lynch films of all time. It does get typically murky and convoluted in the last twenty minutes, and I understand what is being attempted, but it really feels like a switch that was done for style more than story, which is a very David Lynch thing to do. I'm OK with the switch, but I wanted the mystery of the original story to keep playing out. Maybe the reason that I find this film so compelling is that it comes the closest in style and mood to the original first season of "Twin Peaks". Every moment filled with portents, every scene visually unsettling, every music cue intriguing and confounding. This was originally a pilot for a TV series and I could easily see Lynch stringing out his mystery for several seasons if he could be freed from the demands that he solve it, like the demands that threw off the second season of "Twin Peaks". Although I guess there is a risk that it could turn out to be ""Lost".
The sound design of the film is one of the main reasons that seeing this in a theater was the right thing to do. The music penetrates the brain and body differently in the ambience of a packed auditorium. When the singing sequences take place, their juxtaposition with the darker ambient sounds and haunting Angelo Badalamenti score are more powerful. There is a sense of danger when Justin Theroux's character meets the Cowboy in a forgotten corral on Mulholland, the silence of the scene, the footsteps on the ground and the quiet voice that emanates from the ambiguous figure are all heightened by a theatrical presentation.
There are a string of clues that lead to the resolution, if you can call it that, and they are woven into the story effectively, but we are left with a dangling set of story threads that don't seem to pay off. If Rita is a complete invention in the mind of Diane, as a stand in for the lover who has jilted her, then I suppose it will just be that we came in the middle of someone else's dream, and we can't really expect any answers. This though would have been the flow line of the TV series that I now wish had been produced. The surreal plot twists at the end extricate Lynch from having to deal with these points, and they do so in a way that will make analyzing the film fun for eternity.
As is usual, the ambiguity at the end will delight some and frustrate others. I can appreciate both points of view, and I am just a little surprised that I find myself late to the conversation. I hope all the good speculative discussion has room for one more chattering head. I'm in.
