Let me Begin by stating that I have nothing but admiration for James Cameron and his technical accomplishments with the Avatar films. From the very first film back in 2009 up through this most recent film, Cameron has been pushing the outside of the envelope reaching for greater and greater cinematic experiences to make movie going worthwhile. As far as I'm concerned an Avatar movie deserves to be on the biggest screen that you can find with the best sound system available and ideally in 3D. That's because the Craftsman Behind These films are at the Apex of their talent.
I have to admit however that the Avatar films don't hold my interest as far as storytelling is concerned. They are interesting enough while I'm watching them, and create enough suspense to engage me for the three hours or so, that they take up. On the other hand I have never felt the need to rewatch the films in any setting other than a theater. Unlike a film series like the Lord of the Rings, these stories do not feel essential. They are entertainments rather than universals. As a consequence I don't find myself invested in waiting for the next movie to come out. It took more than a dozen years for the first sequel to show up, and I was fine with that. It's only taken about 4 years for this second sequel to show, and to be honest I wasn't even sure I was interested in seeing it. I'm glad I did because I enjoyed the spectacle, I just can't seem to warm up to any of the characters or care much about what happens to the cultures being presented here. I'm not sure if that is a storytelling fault or simply result of the genre that is being developed, although I am strongly anticipating the third film Dune franchise.
Fire and Ash, continues the story of the navi and the metamorphized Jake Sully. I mostly don't remember how it is that this human became a navi, and the fact that antagonist characters do the same thing is also somehow outside my frame of reference. And once again I don't really care. The film is mostly a series of chases and battles fought in the lustly designed environments that have been created on the planet of Pandora. The jungles and oceans of that world are visually stimulating and filled with creatures and Flora that are spectacular to behold especially in 3D. Is one of my friends jokes the planet deserves to be in 3D because the characters are barely 2D.
Like the previous versions of the film series, fire and Ash feels like it comes to a stopping point, and then adds another 40 minutes. You are going to get your money's worth no matter how unnecessary it is for the films to be as long as they are. Because of the plot line repeats itself so often in the same movie there's not a lot of suspense about the story only about how the incidents that occur in the story are going to be resolved. From my point of view that's not a great way to stay engaged with characters or long-term story arc,
A smart person will never bet against James Cameron when it comes to box office success. This movie appears to be doing as well as the previous sequel and although there has been some talk of pausing the planned 4th and fifth films, can't see that happening. I was a little surprised that the lamb community was not interested in a show on this particular film, which might have left me believing that there was going to be a serious drop off in interest. It certainly isn't the case with the General Cinema audience, so maybe it's just a function of the time of year.
As I've already said, the film is worth seeing if you are seeing it in a theater on a big screen with the purpose of enjoying a mass entertainment. If you're looking for anything else however there are plenty of superior options. As most of you who've read these posts before probably know, I almost always want a movie to succeed, even those that let me down occasionally. Avatar fire and Ash is entertaining enough, but outside of the technical craft and look of the film, I think it's flatlined.
